One rule for the airline, another for everyone else
Drukair sells tour packages.
That's not a rumor or a complaint pulled from a tour operator's grievance list. It's a fact. The national airline, a state-owned enterprise, subsidized and protected has moved into the tour business, competing directly with the licensed private operators whose entire livelihood depends on selling Bhutan to the world.
Nobody seems to find this strange. They should.
The setup
Bhutan's tourism model is deliberately restricted. Arrivals are capped by policy. Every international tourist must book through a licensed Bhutanese tour operator. The Sustainable Development Fee sits on top of every booking. Access to the country is, by design, a managed and regulated pipeline.
That pipeline has exactly two commercial airlines flying into it: Drukair and Bhutan Airlines. Paro International Airport handles all of it, one runway, surrounded by mountains, cleared only by pilots who have trained specifically for it. There is no easy way around this. If you want to fly into Bhutan commercially, you are already working inside a captive market.
Drukair knows this. It's the reason the airline has been profitable even when load factors would sink a carrier operating anywhere with actual competition.
The asymmetry
Here's the question that deserves a direct answer: if a state-owned airline is allowed to sell tour packages, entering the market that private operators occupy, why are those same private operators not allowed to start an airline?
They cannot. The regulatory structure does not permit it. An airline licence in Bhutan is not something a group of tour operators can collectively apply for and receive. The barriers are not purely technical or safety-related. They are structural, and they protect incumbents.
So we have a one-way door. The airline walks through it into the tour business. The tour operators cannot walk through it in the other direction.
That's not a market. That's a hierarchy.
The business case nobody is making
Set aside fairness for a moment and look at the numbers.
Bhutan's licensed tour operators collectively handle close to 100 percent of inbound international tourism. Every tourist who enters the country has already passed through a tour operator before they board a flight. The customer relationship, the booking, the trust; it all sits with the operators, not with the airline.
If those operators came together and launched a shared carrier, what would the load factor look like? The answer is obvious. You wouldn't be guessing at demand. You would already own it. An 80 to 90 percent market share isn't a projection, it's a description of the existing customer base.
The capital requirement is real. Aircraft leases, crew training, maintenance contracts, insurance — none of that is cheap. But Bhutan's tourism numbers, while deliberately kept low in volume, are kept deliberately high in yield. The Sustainable Development Fee alone generates significant revenue per arrival. The per-tourist spend is among the highest in the region. A small fleet serving a high-yield, pre-committed passenger base is a different financial model than a low-cost carrier chasing volume.
It is not obviously unworkable. Someone should be running the numbers.
What the current structure does
When a state airline enters the tour package market, it doesn't just compete on price. It competes with the institutional weight of a government-backed entity behind it. Tour operators cannot match that. They can't absorb losses the same way. They can't access capital on the same terms. They can't lean on the same relationships.
What this produces, over time, is a quiet consolidation of the tourism value chain into government hands. The private sector handles the labor-intensive, margin-thin parts. The state captures the more profitable positions.
Private tour operators in Bhutan are not large corporations. Many are family-run businesses that have spent years building relationships with specific international markets, with repeat clients, with niche tourism products such as birdwatching, archery tours, high-altitude treks. These are exactly the kinds of operators who sustain the "high value, low volume" model that Bhutan's tourism policy depends on.
Allowing a state airline to undercut them on packaged tours, while simultaneously blocking them from competing in the aviation space, is a policy choice. It's worth naming it as one.
The comparison that doesn't get made
Other small mountain nations have found ways to create shared aviation infrastructure through private cooperation. Regional carriers in the Pacific islands. Consortium models in East Africa. The logic is similar everywhere: when the market is small and the geography is captive, fragmented ownership destroys value. Coordinated ownership captures it.
Bhutan's tour operators are already, in a practical sense, coordinated. They share the same regulatory framework, the same SDF structure, the same Paro bottleneck. The coordination infrastructure exists. What doesn't exist is the political will to let them use it vertically.
What a serious policy conversation would ask
Not whether tour operators deserve an airline. That's the wrong frame.
The right questions are: Does the current structure serve Bhutan's tourism goals, or does it serve the airline's balance sheet? Is the restriction on tour operator airlines based on a genuine assessment of risk, or is it a protection mechanism dressed up as regulation? And if Drukair can legitimately sell tour packages on the grounds that vertical integration improves the visitor experience than why does that logic stop at the airline's front door?
These are questions for the Department of Tourism, for the regulators, and frankly for the tour operators themselves. The idea of a collectively owned carrier isn't radical. It's a rational response to a market structure that is already, quietly, being tilted against them.
"The cattle on the Paro–Thimphu road move at their own pace. Everyone waits."
"That patience is admirable in daily life. As a posture toward a regulatory system that holds one player to different rules than another, it's worth reconsidering."


Comments
Post a Comment