Workplace safety awards are not the point
The Labour Department held its Occupational Health and Safety awards last week. Certificates were given out. Speeches were made. A safety officer was recognized for three years of good work. Everyone went home feeling good about themselves.
Meanwhile, a quarter of the 87 workplaces assessed scored below 50 percent. One scored 22.88 percent.
Let me be direct: an award ceremony is not a safety program. It is a press release with refreshments.
Start with the number nobody wants to say out loud
22.88 percent.
That is not a company that needs "advice." That is a company where workers are showing up every day in conditions that the government's own assessors rated as dangerously inadequate. What happened to that company after the assessment? Was it fined? Was it shut down? Was the owner called in and told to fix it within 30 days or face consequences?
The BBS report says companies with poor performance are "penalised and advised to improve their safety standards." What does "penalised" mean? How much? Was anyone prosecuted? Has any company ever had its operating license suspended for safety violations?
If the answer is no, then the penalty is not a penalty. It is a suggestion. And suggestions do not keep workers alive.
87 companies. That's it?
Bhutan has hundreds of registered businesses operating across manufacturing, construction, hydropower, mining, and services. The Labour Department assessed 87 of them this year. That number has not been questioned in any coverage I have seen.
It should be.
If your workforce safety program covers fewer than a hundred companies eight years after it started, you do not have a program. You have a pilot that never scaled. The Ministry needs to explain why the assessment rate is this low, what the plan is to expand it, and on what timeline.
"We want companies to comply on their own, without monitoring," said Sonam Geley Dorjee, Deputy Executive Engineer with the Labour Department.
I understand the aspiration. But you do not get compliance culture without enforcement first. Singapore did not build workplace safety by hoping companies would develop a conscience. It built it through mandatory standards, real penalties, and inspectors who showed up unannounced. You earn the trust that allows self-compliance. You do not start there.
The spin on stricter standards
In 2018, 77 companies scored 70 percent or above. This year, 15 did.
The official explanation is that assessment standards have become more stringent. That may be true. But it is also possible that companies which performed well in 2018 have since gotten worse, and stricter standards are revealing what was always there.
We do not know, because the audit report is not yet published. It is "expected next week" — which means the Ministry announced the results of an assessment before the assessment documentation was complete. That is backwards. Publish the report. Then hold the ceremony.
If the drop from 77 to 15 is entirely explained by a higher bar, show that data. Break it down by sector. Show the trend lines for repeat participants. Tell us whether the companies that scored well in previous years are still scoring well, or whether they have backslid. "Stricter standards" as an explanation without supporting data is not analysis. It is comfort food for officials who do not want to answer harder questions.
What is the injury rate?
Here is what is missing from this entire conversation: the number of workplace injuries and fatalities in Bhutan per year.
That is the only number that matters. Assessment scores are inputs. Dead and injured workers are outputs. The entire purpose of an OHS program is to reduce the second number.
Where is it?
If the Labour Department is running annual assessments, tracking scores over time, and giving out awards, it should also be publishing annual data on workplace injuries, near-misses, and deaths by sector. If compliance scores are going up, injuries should be going down. If they are not, then the assessment methodology is measuring the wrong things.
Every developed economy with a functioning safety regime publishes this data. It creates accountability. It tells you whether the program is working. The Ministry should commit to publishing it.
On JICA
The JICA Bhutan Office was also recognized at the ceremony for "advancing occupational health and safety in Bhutan."
Eight years in, Bhutan should not still be dependent on a Japanese development agency to advance its own workplace safety standards. JICA's involvement is not a problem in itself, external expertise is useful. But recognition at a national safety awards ceremony suggests the Ministry still sees JICA as a co-author of its program rather than a past contributor.
The question to ask is: what has the Labour Department built that will outlast JICA's involvement? What internal capacity, what institutional knowledge, what enforcement infrastructure? If the answer is unclear, that is the next thing to fix.
What Prabachan Giri's award actually means
Prabachan Giri was recognized as an individual for three consecutive years of safety leadership at Tashi Metals. This is genuinely good. Naming individuals matters. It changes behavior in ways that company-level awards do not.
But why did it take until 2026 to recognize an individual? The program started in 2018. Seven years of company-level awards without once naming a person. That delay tells you something about how the Ministry has framed this program as a compliance exercise for organizations, not a professional practice for people.
There are safety officers in every major Bhutanese company. Most of them are doing their jobs with no recognition and no career ladder. If the Ministry wants to build a real safety culture, it should make occupational health and safety a recognized profession with training pathways, certification standards, and a salary premium. One award for one individual once every seven years is not a pipeline.
What the Ministry should do, specifically
Stop announcing results before the audit report is published. Publish the report first, every year, on a fixed date.
Name the worst performers publicly. Safety is a public interest issue. A company scoring 22.88 percent has workers whose families deserve to know.
State the penalties clearly. Not "penalised and advised", how much, for what, and what triggers escalation to license suspension.
Publish annual injury and fatality data by sector, alongside assessment scores.
Set a target for assessment coverage. 87 companies is not enough. If there are 500 companies operating in covered sectors, assess 500.
Build a professional certification pathway for safety officers. Give them status, training, and a reason to stay in the role.
These are not complicated things. They are standard features of a functioning workplace safety regime. Other countries have done them. Bhutan can too.
The workers showing up every morning at construction sites, factories, and hydropower tunnels are not waiting for an annual ceremony. They are waiting for a system that takes their safety seriously enough to enforce it.
That is what the Ministry is actually being asked to deliver.

Comments
Post a Comment